Forum Topic

Dirty tricks revealed in todays Evening Standard.

A Tory candidate was accused today of trying to smear a Labour MP who has fought back from a stroke. Greg Hands, the Conservative candidate for Hammersmith & Fulham, has issued an election leaflet highlighting the recent illness of Iain Coleman. The document tells voters that Mr Coleman was left with "slurred speech and problems walking" after suffering the stroke. It goes on to point out the Labour MP has not spoken or voted in Parliament since last May because of his condition. The leaflet comes days after the Conservatives rounded on Labour for waging a "dirty tricks" campaign ahead of the general election. But Labour said Mr Hands's action showed the Conservatives were resorting to underhand techniques. One Labour official described the leaflet as the "lowest of the low". Mr Coleman, 47, had a stroke last July. Although he had temporary paralysis in one of his legs, he was back at work in September and is expected to make a full recovery. The MP, who had a majority of 2,015 over the Conservatives at the 2001 election, questioned his opponent's sincerity. He said: "I thought he [Hands] was being a bit snide. It is a very marginal seat and [the Conservatives] are going to fight a vigorous campaign. They say they want to fight a clean campaign and we will judge them on what they do." In the leaflet, distributed across the constituency, Mr Hands writes: "Local residents will have seen in the papers reports that the local MP has had a stroke. Due to his illness, the MP has not spoken or voted in Parliament since May 2004 and has made no known public appearances in Hammersmith & Fulham in the last eight months." Mr Hands adds: "We wish the MP all the best for a swift recovery and look forward to a vigorous campaign. "We need to make sure that all the issues like tax, the economy, the NHS and schools are properly debated." Speaking to the Evening Standard, Mr Hands expressed surprise his remarks had caused distress, saying: "The message was very clear that we were wishing him the best for a swift recovery." Labour accused the Conservatives of fighting the "dirtiest possible" personalised campaign. A party spokesman said: "They claim that Labour's questioning of Michael Howard's record as the minister who gave us the poll tax and three million unemployed, and who supported 15 per cent interest rates, is part of a dirty campaign. But when it comes to dirty campaigns, Michael Howard's Tories wrote the book."

Paul Fisher ● 7379d2 Comments

Paul I can’t say that I find the increasing use of political smear campaigning to be a positive move for anyone, politicians, political parties or the electorate. In this case, I agree with the Labour Party in that Greg Hands and the Conservative Party in attacking Iain Coleman over his ill health have launched a truly despicable campaign. However I realise that such campaigning is with us and will no doubt stay with us and that over time such smear campaigning will no doubt depreciate politics further in the mind of the electorate. Mr Coleman seems not to be guilty of anything save for a period of unexpected ill health. There are many who hold public office who ought not to be there for far worse reasons than unexpected ill health. Margaret Hodge and Dame Shirley Porter immediately spring to mind. As we all know, nobody is forced into standing for election but at the same time everyone realises that politics can be a very dirty game and when the stakes are high, so are the risks of very negative smear campaigning. All that these smearing campaigns do is to engender a perception amongst the electorate that with notable exceptions, very few politicians can actually be trusted. Anyone who puts themselves up for election as a representative of the people needs to be fully aware that any proverbial skeletons in their cupboards either before gaining office, or gained during office may well be used against them. But in a democratic society it is right that the political system, the electorate and the media have a right to investigate issues and equally to be expected that politicians should have nothing to fear from scrutiny, if the politicians have done nothing to jeopardise his or her position of trust. I can’t see anything wrong with the Labour Party reminding the electorate of Michael Howard's record as a minister of state or of the genuine failings of any Conservative MP or of the Conservative Party in general. I equally wouldn’t find anything wrong with the Conservative Party highlighting the genuine failings of any Labour MP or of the Labour Party. I do however have a major problem with any politician or any political party attempting to score political advantage through attacking someone over his or her physical or mental health.  I wish Mr Coleman a speedy return to full health. What I wish for Mr Hands is unprintable.

Gareth Evans ● 7379d