Forum Topic

I can't offer any suggestions Jennifer, other than to say the most ecological solution is to keep your old car (and keep it in good tune). I was discussing this with a Green party member yesterday and, whilst neither of us has the accurate story, we agreed that the toll on the planet of producing a new car, no matter how frugal and clean, would outweigh the ecological benefits of running a cleaner vehicle for years to come.Of course, nearly all our cars are imported these days and the proportion is fairly certain to increase if Brexit happens, particularly with no deal so it's not good for the economy either.What the cynics conveniently ignore are that we are facing two major difficulties here today.One is global warning, and in terms of cars this is driven by lifetime CO2 emissions, Diesel is still more economical with carbon than is petrol.The second is harmful emissions, where diesel produces more than petrol,no matter how 'clean' (and where even electric vehicles produce brake and tyre dust). You might view this as less catastrophic than global warning (after all it is likely to kill just tens of thousands of people, whereas warming could more or less wipe us out over time, but it's still an issue.  Of course the best thing is to not have, or minimise the use, of any powered vehicle (though even bikes produce brake dust and no doubt shoes produce particulates too!)Not everyone can manage this, or is willing to, but the more we can travel sustainably, the better for everyone especially those who have no realistic option but to drive like, as I understand it, Jennifer.

Guy Lambert ● 2190d

The ease of mass manipulation and how social media and fake news has made what Hitler and the soviets devised now so easy is the real worry here.Statistics get so easily manipulated nowadays that it is absolutely pointless having statistics any more they have been abused to the point of being meaningless.Anything to avoid tackling the real problems and everything to do with making ££££S out of issues by creating hysteria among the masses and then milking it.Trouble is when all these people and organisations & authorities have long gone and the problems still as unsolved as ever , the next generations will just be getting the same.The Petrol/ Diesel issue is so  flaky.All you hear is statistics based on EU air quality.  No-one asks where their base line for air quality is or where the benchmark average is set.  Industrial Europe has been asking that for well over 20 years and still no one is any the wiser.Fact is this country in it's industrial post war peak was hugely polluted.  Life expectancy was short and almost all chronic illnesses were respiratory.Vehicles per 1000 were 100 times more polluting in 1956 than now. Steam engines and diesel engines were in the thousands on the railways, gas was made from Coal,as was electricity and the place was filthy. Trains were braked by asbestos,and insulated with the same.  The London Underground used asbestos in all it's trains stations and brake shoes. In confined tunnels.But in the main we are all living longer and healthier.It is a progressive path of getting cleaner.  Plastics have enabled fresh food in plenty, water where water could not be got to before.But we also have not always been responsible with some items, Plastic in particular.Diesel though is a weird one.  Put your hand over a 1960s diesel exhaust and you will have a filthy ring of black dirt on your hand. But it will wash off.Do the same with a new diesel and you will see no mark.  But... You will have had tiny molecules of exhaust past straight into your skin.R&D in the automotive and industrial engine industry is almost at the point of an almost 100% clean burn fossil fuelled light engines. Highly efficient and non toxic.The mass hysteria and the need for the automotive industry to survive as a profitable industry has led to all the R&D stalling completely worldwide.So the alternatives which are acceptable are no cleaner. They simply pass the toxins to another part of the world.Problem not solved, just passed into someone else back yard, only a few quid is made along the way.

Raymond Havelock ● 2190d