Forum Topic

Malcolm Richards on the local election

I thought this article from Malcolm Richards was refreshingly a refreshing change from all the talk of corruption, vote-rigging and political bias. It is nice to know that someone who has covered the local political scene for decades believes we have usually managed to elect decent committed people.Malcolm Richards was editor of the Richmond and Twickenham times for over thirty years.*******The Malcolm Richards Column: A cross in the right box can move mountainsBy Malcolm RichardsLocal elections are not only a judgement on how local communities are faring but an indication of the popularity of Parliament.Although there has been little evidence in this area that the BNP threat - Labour's current concern - will have any material input, next week's result will offer evidence on Mr Blair's standing and there will be clues on whether David Cameron's greener caring policies have caught the public imagination or if the execution of Charles Kennedy has done permanent harm.When the Conservatives took over in Richmond upon Thames four years ago they broke a Lib Dem 18-year run.Prior to that the Conservatives had held sway in the old boroughs for as long as anyone could remember and were represented in Parliament by high profile MPs like Jeremy Hanley, Sir Anthony Royle and Toby Jessel.It is on the cards that Labour's lack of representation in Richmond upon Thames is set to continue in May but this will have minimal impact on the tussle between the Conservative and Lib Dem giants. What will be more telling is if Mr Cameron's tactics capture voters' hearts as this must be one of the most environmentally conscious corners of the metropolis.It is significant that Marc Cranfield-Adams, who is standing for the Lib Dems in North Richmond Ward, is a Conservative defector and that his former colleague and ex Mayor, Douglas Orchard, has gone in the opposite direction by standing in South Twickenham as an independent with Ukip sympathies.Hounslow has been dominated by the Labour Party with substantial majorities since the 70s.Signs of nationalistic racism which emerged in Isleworth through Phil Andrews and his cronies faded away when they created the successful Isleworth Community Association and appeared to abandon their xenophobic tendencies and concentrate on genuine home grown grievances.It is unlikely that the two National Front candidates standing in Feltham will cause a significant upset, but the breakaway group which has the backing of John Connelly, a former Labour leader fielding 16 candidates under the banner of Hounslow Independent Alliance could upset an apple cart or two.Thirty years ago Hounslow was returning Conservative MPs to Parliament and had control of the boroughs. Some of their MPs, like Barney Hayhoe, held high office. Dudley Smith was a senior executive and journalist with the then influential Sunday Express.The character of the western end has changed radically in the last two decades and the Asian vote is now a decisive factor. The result will be an indication if support is faltering from what has been a consistently loyal sector.There is a lot of cynicism about local democracy and the increasing apathy is defended with jibes about politicians being self seeking and corrupt. But as the viewpoint column in this newspaper reminded readers recently - many lives were sacrificed to ensure that adults have the right to vote.It is unfair to suggest that everyone who seeks public office is doing so to feather their own nest or boost inflated egos. The vast majority genuinely want to ensure we live in a just, fair and efficient society.Certainly the reputations of Tony Arbour and Serge Lourie in in this respect are impeccable.Similarly Hounslow leaders, Conservative Peter Thompson, Labour Colin Ellar and Lib Dem Ray Fincher have shown consistent beneficence.It is the wild cards and fringe parties who emphasise the true value of a democracy and viewpoint has highlighted the valuable contribution the late Richard Meacock made to the local political scene - providing a master class on how the public can keep politicians on their toes.His passion over the resurrection of Richmond ice rink was inspirational. The Lib Dems' failure to prevent its closure or to get a replacement rink constructed was their blackest hour.Local elections should be about local issues and the rink was - and is - for it served both Hounslow and Richmond upon Thames boroughs and provided a much needed outlet for youthful energies which can otherwise turn to violence and vandalism.The defectors and single issue fanatics make local politics colourful and interesting.They remind us that low taxation, cleaner roads and better schools are not the only things that matter to local communities and that a cross in the right box can move mountains or sometimes defrost crucial decisions that have been evasively put on ice.

Mike Hardacre ● 7024d11 Comments

"What new administration. "I'm presuming a new administration has to be formed in the next week or so. Do you know otherwise?"Surely does it not say more about your local councillors in Chiswick if they haven't been representing the locals opposition to the parking policies you dislike as residents?"The Chiswick councillors to the best of my knowledge have protested strongly about the inequalities of the current system. Having been in a minority there was nothing much they could do other than this. Now they have no excuse for not acting."I can't say that I'm surprised you would pay more.  There are evidently more local pressures for parking spaces with its being closer to London, a successful shopping high street in the locale, and good connections to public transport."Even Cllr. Ruth Cadbury, who at one point was responsible for transport in the borough, would disagree with you as she described the differentiated charges as 'unjustifiable'. Pressure for parking spaces explains why controlled parking zones are created in the first place. If an area has a CPZ it probably has pressure on parking spaces so why should one area have more."good connections to public transport"This was used as a justification by the Council but then they were forced to publish the official 'PAL' scores which shows the quality of public transport service in a particular area. This showed that Chiswick scored relatively poorly in the borough and by far the best score was for Hounslow Town which also had the lowest permit charges."There are far more houses in split occupancy in Chiswick than elsewhere and i suspect higher levels of car ownership."According to the National Statistics database both these statements are wrong. Chiswick wards have the lowest levels of car ownership in Hounslow borough and the highest usership of public transport."The costs of managing the Chiswick area must be higher than for the rest of us."It's not clear whether you mean parking or administration in general. For parking - economies of scale would mean that it is relatively cheaper to issue a ticket in Chiswick than say Hounslow."And when you say "some" labour councillors what do you mean?"I mean there were some Labour councillors in Chiswick prior to 2002. Four out of eleven if I recall correctly which would include those from the Gunnersbury ward which has since had its boundaries redrawn but was mainly in Chiswick.

Alice Slater ● 7006d